Neilalien : A Doctor Strange Fansite : A Comic Book Weblog  

PALINDROME

NEILALIEN

A Doctor Strange Fansite
A Comic Book Weblog/Portal
A Steve Ditko Fansite
A Mysterious Palindrome

Links Open Windows

NEILALIEN STATUS
Neilalien.com: not-daily linkblog
Twitter: linkblog RSS & some Doc/geek retweets
Tumblr: linkblog RSS & some Doc/geek reblogs
Facebook: linkblog RSS is working!
Neilalien RSS Feed

- -

Latest Weblog Post:

11 Is A Palindromic Number, and,
A Recusal

Please celebrate with Neilalien his 11th Blogiversary! Exclesior!

That's 1,111 in internet/weblog/dog years. You won't find a better combination of starting earlier and blogging longer in comics-blogging.

But alas, as of today, Neilalien is officially recusing himself from the news, entertainments, and expectations of the near-daily visitor to his website.

Now is a good time- 11 is a palindromic number, of course...

[25 Feb 02011: More...]

- -

Dr. Strange Information
 [Story List] [Powers/Items]
 [Origins] [Book of Names]
 [Many Faces] [Questions/FAQ]
 [Oath #3 Cover Lineup]
 [Historical Sales Numbers]
 [Recommended Reading]

Email Neilalien:
webmaster AT neilalien.com

Excite My Chicken
Ask The Mysterious Orb
Black Jack #1
Neilalien T-Shirts
Neilalien Site Map

Neilalien Blog Archive
02020: 010203040506
02020: 070809101112
02019: 010203040506
02019: 070809101112
02018: 010203040506
02018: 070809101112
02017: 010203040506
02017: 070809101112
02016: 010203040506
02016: 070809101112
02015: 010203040506
02015: 070809101112
02014: 010203040506
02014: 070809101112
02013: 010203040506
02013: 070809101112
02012: 010203040506
02012: 070809101112
02011: 010203040506
02011: 070809101112
02010: 010203040506
02010: 070809101112
02009: 010203040506
02009: 070809101112
02008: 010203040506
02008: 070809101112
02007: 010203040506
02007: 070809101112
02006: 010203040506
02006: 070809101112
02005: 010203040506
02005: 070809101112
02004: 010203040506
02004: 070809101112
02003: 010203040506
02003: 070809101112
02002: 010203040506
02002: 070809101112
02001: 010203040506
02001: 070809101112
02000: 02-080910, 1112
More: OriginPre-Blog Links

- -

Overheard in a comic con bathroom:

"We have a new character... named Dr. Strange... Twas Steve's idea."
- Stan Lee, letter to Comic Reader #16, 23 February 01963, as quoted in Steve Ditko's 32-Page Package v.5 Tsk! Tsk!

"I'm telling you, the only reason that Neilalien has lasted so long is because he kills younger, more innocent, bloggers and drinks their blood in some twisted Ditko-inspired mystical ceremony."
- Fanboy Rampage

"Is that the Eye of Yaphet Kotto?"
- A demon, Marvel Comics Presents #20

- -

Creators/Publishers: Neilalien would love to help,
but he does not accept free comics or review submissions.

"Do not accept for review a book you are
predisposed to dislike, or committed by
friendship to like." - John Updike


PORTAL

Alpha News Surf
Comics Reporter [RIP]
Comic Book Resources [Doc]
PreviewsWorld [New Releases]
Bleeding Cool
Comics Chronicles [Blog]
Comics Continuum
ICv2 [Comics] [Tops]
IMDb: DSitMOM Movie News
IMDb: Doctor Strange Movie News
Marvel.com [Doc] [Tumblr]
Newsarama
Sanctum Sanctorum [PTor]
Twitter: "ditko"
Twitter: "doctor strange" ["dr."]
Reddit: r/comicbooks
Reddit: r/doctorstrange
SYFY Wire Marvel News
Yahoo Finance: Disney News

Linkablogotron 2099
» Comic Weblog Update-A-Tron
» Comic Book Blog Updates
Att-Def-Dis/Sean T. Collins
C-Dog's Cryptonaut-In-Exile
Ditko Comics [In Print]
Four Realities
Franklin Harris
The Hurting
LinkMachineGo
Matt Dembicki
Progressive Ruin [Counter]

Comic Book Portal (cont.)
Doc: Wikipedia
Doc: Howard Hallis [Collection]
 [Custom Covers] [Everything]
Doc: Archive [IG] [Tw]
Doc: Sorcerer Supreme
Doc: Original Art Gallery
Doc: Complete [App List]
Doc: Sanctum Sanctorum
Doc: Lesser Book Vishanti
Doc: Strange Scribe
Doc: Toonopedia
Doc: Micro-Heroes
Doc: Fuck Yeah Dumb Magician
Doc: Fuckyeah! Doc Tumblr
Ditko: Ditko FAQ [UFO]
Ditko: Blake Bell [Facebook]
Ditko: Ditko-L [Yahoo Group]
Ditko: Ditkomania [Yahoo Group]
Ditko: Ditko-Kirby [Yahoo Group]
Ditko: Wikipedia [Objectivism]
Ditko: Ditko Cultist
Ditko: Ditko Fever
Ditko: Ditkoland Message Board
Ditko: Steveditko.com
Ditko: Biography
Ditko: IMDb
Lee: Real [Twitter]
Lee: Wikipedia
Lee: IMDb
Brunner: Official Site
Colan: Official Site
Colan: Genecolan [Yahoo Group]
Englehart: Official Site
Stern: Roger Stern MB
Question: VicSage.com [News]
13th Dimension
20th Century Danny Boy
4chan /co/ Comics & Cartoons
ACT-I-VATE [LJ] [Wikipedia]
Adventures In Poor Taste
Adventures In The Marvelous Zone
Alterna Comics
Arthur's Marvel Comics Reprints
Atomic Junk Shop
Bags And Boards
Barry's Pearls
The Beat
Beware The Valkyries
Bill Mantlo Project
NYC: Black Comic Book Festival
Black Comix
Black Comix Arts Festival [BCAF]
Black Girl Nerds [Tw]
Bklyn: Blerd City Con
Bobster's Micro-Heroes
Bondage Cover Of The Day
Booksteve's Library
Box Office Mojo: Marvel Comics
Broken Frontier
Bklyn: Brooklyn Book Festival [Comics]
Bklyn: Brooklyn Comic Con
Bklyn: Brooklyn Zine Fest
Calvin and Hobbes [Search]
Capeless Crusader
Captain Comics
Cartoonist Pics
Cartoonists Of Color Database
Chain Letters For Disturbed Children
Chris Arrant
Clandestine Critic
Clifford Meth
Colleen Coover
Comic Art Magazine
Bklyn: Comic Arts Brooklyn
ComicBloc Forums
ComicBook.com
Comic Book Bin
Comic Book Cartography [4CP]
Comic Book Conventions [Cons]
Comic Book Database
Comic Book Drug Reference
Comic Book Fonts
Comic Book Legal Defense Fund
Comic Book Research [NYPL]
Comic Book Research [Yale]
Comic Book Tropes
Comic Book Writer's Info Page
Comicon [Pulse] [MB]
Comic-Con Int'l [San Diego]
Comic Coverage
Comic Crusaders
Comic Foundry
Comic Life
ComicMix
Comic News International
Comic Pants
ComicPress [for WordPress]
Comic Publishers Submission Guidelines
Comic Readers [MB]
Comic Shop Locator
Comic Shop News
ComicSpace
Comic Vine
Comic Widows
Comic World News [MB]
Comics212.net
ComicsAlliance
Comics Bulletin
Comics Buyer's Guide Xtra
 [Sales Charts/Analysis]
Comics Comics
Comics Commentary [Twt] [Tmb]
Comics Curmudgeon
Comics Grid
Comics Guaranty's Census
Comics In Context [Sanderson]
The Comics Journal
Comics Lifestyle
ComicsML Resource Page
Comics Podcasts Network
Comics Research & Such
Comics: The Gathering
Comics Worth Reading
Comiks Debris
Comixfan Forums
Comixology [Tucker Stone]
Comixtalk
Complete Marvel Reading Order [Doc]
Consequentialart's S.A.C.
Covered
Crime Comic Books 40s/50s
Crivens! Comics & Stuff
The Daily Cartoonist
Dean Haspiel
Deconstructing Liechtenstein
Defenders Fansite
Delusional Honesty
Bklyn: Desert Island Comics
Digital Comic Museum
Digitalwebbing.com [Blog] [MB]
Dispatches From The Fridge
Diversions Of The Groovy Kind
Don Martin Dictionary
DoomRocket
Drawing Board [MBs]
Eddie Campbell: Comic Book Craft
Encyclopedia Of Pulp Heroes
The Escapist [Dark Dungeons]
Ethan Persoff [Problems] [Tw]
Ever-Ending Battle
Exhibit A Press [Batton Lash]
Eye On Comics
Fantagraphics Books
Fantasy Merchant
First Comics News
Fred Hembeck [Tumblr]
Free Comic Book Day
Friends of Lulu [RIP 02011]
Giant Size Marvel [Doc]
Girlamatic.com
Girl-Wonder.org [Read Comics]
Gizmodo [comics]
Glyph Comics Awards
Gone & Forgotten
Grand Comic Book Database
Graphic Policy
Graphic Smash [RIP]
Hannibal Tabu [Soapbox]
Heat Vision
Hero Complex [LA Times]
Hero Initiative [was ACTOR]
HeroMachine
High Grade Comics
The Hooded Utilitarian
House To Astonish [X-Axis]
IDW [Top Shelf]
IGN Comics
I Like Comics Too
Image Comics [Blog]
ImageTexT [Comics at UFla]
Indy Magazine
Ink Spill
Int'l Comic Arts Association [ICAA]
Int'l Comic Arts Forum
Isotope Comics [SF]
Jack Kirby Museum [Kirby Blog]
 [Dynamics] [Simon/Kirby Blog]
Jeet Heer [Comics] [Ditko]
NYC: JHU Comic Books
Jim Shooter
Ken Lowery [Ringwood]
Kerry Callen
Kevin Church
Komikwerks
Kurt Busiek [Blog] [Twitter]
The Lexicon Of Comicana
Major Spoilers
Manchu
Manga Curmudgeon
Manga Iconography [Wikipedia]
Mark Evanier's News From ME
List/Learned/Comic Book Industry
Marvel Bullpen Bulletins Index
Marvel Chronology Project
Marvel Comics Creators Hbk
Marvel In The Silver Age
Marvel Universe Appendix
 [Dr. Strange Characters]
Marvel Universe Message Board
Marvel Value Stamps Index
Marvel Zombie Society APA
Masked Avenger Studios
Master List of Comic Stores
Meetup Groups: Comic Books
Metrokitty
NYC: Midtown Comics
Mile High Comics [Tales]
MillarWorld
Mindless Ones
Modern Tales
Monitor Duty
MTV Splash Page
Multiversity Comics
Museum of Black Superheroes
Museum of Comic/Cartoon Art
 [MoCCA] [Tumblr]
National Public Radio: "comics"
Neil Gaiman's Journal
New Republic: Comics
NYC: NYCBM [Big Apple Comic Con]
NYC: New York Comic-Con
NYT ArtsBeat: Graphic Books
The Nib
Nick Caputo
No Flying, No Tights
Oh No Robot
OniKimono Links For Creators
On Panel [Bill K.]
Ookla The Mok
Operation Comix Relief
Ormes Society
The Outhouse
Panel And Pixel
Panel To Panel
The Panelists
Pappy's Golden Age Comics
Parkerspace
Paste: Comics
Paul Gravett
Peculiar Art of Mr. Frahm
Pencil Ink
PeterDavid.net
Periodic Table of Comic Books
Pipeline Comics [Augie De Blieck Jr.]
Pirated Thoughts: Comics
Poopsheet
PopCultureShock
PopImage [News]
PopMatters: Comics
POVonline.com [Kirby FAQ]
POWER In Comics
Project Rooftop
Publishers Weekly Comics
Pulp of the Day
PvPonline.com
Quotes On Comics
Reading With Pictures
Rebus Books
r.a.c.marvel.universe [GoogGrps]
Religious Affiliations/CBCs [Doc]
Rick Veitch
R. Sikoryak [Carousel]
Runners Universe
Sam Henderson [Magic Whistle]
The Savage Critics
Scans_Daily [Doc] [Ditko]
Scoop!
Scott McCloud [Morning Improv]
Scryptic Studios
Seanbaby.com Hostess Page
Sean Howe [Twitter] [Tumblr]
Sequart [Previews]
Sequential
Sequential Crush
Sequential Swap
Sequential Tart [MB]
ShakingThrough.net Comics
The Shallow Brigade [Tw]
Small Press & Alt Comics Expo
 [SPACE]
Small Press Expo [SPX]
Society Of Illustrators
Space Art In Children's Books
Spiderfan.org
The Spinner Rack
Sterling Silver Comics
Strip Panel Naked
Stripper's Guide
Superhero Dictionary [Strange]
Superhero Food
Superhero Hype
Superhero Songs
Super Marketing: Ads In Comics
Supervillain
Talk About Comics
Teachingcomics.org [NACAE]
Texts From Superheroes
Thought Balloonists
Todd Klein
Tony Isabella [Tips] [old Tips]
Too Busy Thinking
Toonopedia
Topless Robot
Toth Fans
Trapped In A Lyric
Treasury Comics Gallery
TwoMorrows Publishing [Blog]
Visual Linguist [Neil Cohn]
Vogelein Self-Pub Resources
Vulture › Comics
Watching The Watchmen
The Webcomic List
Webcomics Nation
What's New? With Phil & Dixie
Who Created The Comic Books?
Wizard World
Women In Refrigerators
Women Write About Comics
World Famous Comics
You Don't Read Comics

In Absentia/Memoriam
A Trout In The Milk
Big Sunny D/Cakes And Money
 [Cakes 2.0] [Insult To Injury]
Bookslut [Comicbookslut]
The Brill Building
Clea's Cave
Comic Book Galaxy
 [ADD Blog] [Trouble With Comics]
Comics Reporter
Dave's Long Box
Earth Minds Are Weak
Egon
Fanboy Rampage
Flat Earth
Franklin's Findings/Culture Shock
Ghost In The Machine
Grotesque Anatomy/Sporadic Sequential
Gutterninja
I Am Not The Beastmaster
In Sequence
Jog The Blog
The Johnny Bacardi Show
Lady, That's My Skull
The Low Road
Majic 12
Motime Like The Present [Archive]
Polite Dissent
Pop Culture Gadabout
Postmodernbarney
Ringwood
Tangognat
Thought Balloons
Unqualified Offerings
Weblog Wannabe
When Fangirls Attack

PURPLE GEMS

Death of Doctor Strange five-issue mini-series by Jed MacKay and Lee Garbett announced for September

[13 June 02021]

- -

Upcoming Marvel solicits include a mini-series using the Defenders name, Doctor Strange back in Savage Avengers after a Nightmare story-arc without him- and new better Steve Ditko writing credits for Dr. Strange?

Marvel August 02021 solicits:

It looks more like a Secret Defenders cast than an actual Defenders cast- meh- but we shall see.

DEFENDERS #1 (OF 5)
AL EWING (W)
JAVIER RODRIGUEZ (A/C)
VARIANT COVER BY MARCOS MARTIN
DEADPOOL 30TH VARIANT COVER BY ROB LIEFELD
VARIANT COVER BY RON LIM
SILVER SURFER VARIANT COVER BY PEACH MOMOKO
SILVER SURFER BLACK VARIANT COVER BY PEACH MOMOKO
REBORN VARIANT COVER BY CARLOS PACHECO
HIDDEN GEM VARIANT COVER BY GEORGE PEREZ
SUPERSTARS AL EWING & JAVIER RODRIGUEZ REUNITE
FOR A COSMOS-COLLIDING JOURNEY!
When existence itself faces extraordinary threats, it needs an extraordinary defense! That's when you call... THE DEFENDERS!
DOCTOR STRANGE and the MASKED RAIDER take a non-team of Marvel's weirdest, wildest heroes on a mission that will uncover the hidden architecture of reality itself! This cosmos was not the first to exist... but if the DEFENDERS can't track Marvel's oldest villain through the deepest trenches of time- it might be the last!
32 PGS./Rated T+ $3.99

- -

SAVAGE AVENGERS #23
GERRY DUGGAN (W)
PATCH ZIRCHER (A)
Cover by VALERIO GIANGIORDANO
WHATEVER HAPPENED TO SHUMA-GORATH?
Even elder gods need eldercare. You thought your 2020 sucked, but Kulan Gath was eating Shuma-Gorath in small bites for the last year. Dr. Strange and Conan perform a wellness check. 'Nuff said!
32 PGS./Parental Advisory $3.99

- -

STRANGE ACADEMY #12
SKOTTIE YOUNG (W)
HUMBERTO RAMOS (A/C)
CHARACTER VARIANT COVER BY ARTHUR ADAMS
The person who shattered Toth is revealed, and it brings the second story arc of STRANGE ACADEMY to a rip-roaring climax!!!
Pieces of the Marvel Universe and Doctor Strange's past come back to haunt not Stephen Strange, but the students of The Strange Academy.
But that doesn't wash the hands of the person at Strange Academy who may just bring the whole. School. Down.
32 PGS./Rated T+ $3.99

- -

Marvel June 02021 solicits:

DOCTOR STRANGE EPIC COLLECTION: MASTER OF THE MYSTIC ARTS TPB (NEW PRINTING)

The credits say "Written by STAN LEE & STEVE DITKO"!
And then "Penciled by STEVE DITKO"

Is that new? Neilalien was looking through some of his old Doctor Strange collections. The Essential "phone book" has Lee as Writer and Ditko as Illustrator. The Masterworks has Lee as Writer and Ditko as Co-Plotter.

- -

SAVAGE AVENGERS #21
GERRY DUGGAN (W)
PATCH ZIRCHER (A)
Cover by VALERIO GIANGIORDANO
Nightmare comes for the Marvel Universe and the Doctor is out, but luckily, Conan and Ghost Rider are IN. Flaming skulls are things Conan usually extinguishes with swords, but he's vaguely okay with Johnny Blaze.
32 PGS./Parental Advisory $3.99

- -

Marvel July 02021 solicits:

SAVAGE AVENGERS #22
GERRY DUGGAN (W)
PATCH ZIRCHER (A)
Cover by VALERIO GIANGIORDANO
Conan and Ghost Rider get to the bottom of Nightmare's machinations and his werewolves' origins... and Johnny Blaze isn't the first Ghost Rider that Conan has encountered- he knew one back in Hyboria that rode around on a GIANT SPIDER. This chapter proves you can't spell 'flashback' without the 'AAH!'
32 PGS./Parental Advisory $3.99

DOCTOR STRANGE EPIC COLLECTION: THE VAMPIRIC VERSES TPB
Collecting DOCTOR STRANGE, SORCERER SUPREME #14-33 and GHOST RIDER (1990) #12.

MARVEL-VERSE: DOCTOR STRANGE GN-TPB
Collecting UNCANNY ORIGINS #12, DOCTOR STRANGE (1974) #55, MARVEL ADVENTURES SUPER HEROES (2008) #5 and material from STRANGE TALES (1951) #126-127 and MARVEL FANFARE (1982) #5.

[30 May 02021]

- -

Marvel, Magic And Strange Tales [Part 1] [Part 2] [Part 3]
[Marvel In The Silver Age]
["I don't think Stan Lee liked Doctor Strange, at least not at first..."]

[18 May 02021]

- -

Collecting links re: the new negative Stan Lee biography True Believer: The Rise and Fall of Stan Lee by Abraham Riesman

The Stan Lee Story That Tore Apart Marvel Comics
[Slate book excerpt about that infamous 01966 Nat Freedland New York Herald Tribune piece]

How 'True Believer' Untangles Stan Lee's Complicated Legacy [Hollywood Reporter interview with Riesman]

The One Detail From The New Stan Lee Biography That Confirms Lee's Visionary Genius [cons: a credit hog with a string of flops; pros: selling Marvel comics, managerial/editorial acuity, the interconnected universe, snappy comic-book dialogue and rhythmic narration, trying to get Marvel into Hollywood before its time]

Roy Thomas, Former Marvel Editor, Pushes Back On New Stan Lee Biography [Kirby claims and misrememberings get a pass while Lee's are given devious motives; Marvel's writer rates lagged DC so the artist rates could be better; etc.]

Riesman himself doesn't seem to understand the full variety of ways that the 'Marvel Method' worked. It was begun primarily to benefit the artists- so that, at a time when Stan was virtually the company's sole writer, they wouldn't have to sit on their hands earning no money until he had time to bang out a full script for them. It turned out to have other, unintended consequences, like increasing the action quota and visual appeal of the stories. Then the scripter would swoop in and tie things together with whatever words were needed to augment the pictures and add flavor to the sequence...
But, no matter how well the Random House publicity machine manages to hype this book, as long as it stands as currently published, with Stan all but written off as an inveterate liar whose most important creation was his public persona (when it was actually the concept and direction of the Marvel Universe, an idea that was anathema to Jack Kirby, as per in-book quotes), it will remain undeserving of the high praise heaped upon it by people who, for the most part, don't really know what the hell they're talking about.

Review And Fact Checking: Abraham Riesman: "True Believer, The Rise And Fall Of Stan Lee" [Barry's Pearls of Comic Book Wisdom] ["There are a dozen books that see Stan Lee as a God, this one treats him as the devil. I was hoping for a book that saw him as human... It never shows Stan's point of view."; it reads like a biography of Hank Aaron's 1,300 strikeouts by someone who's never seen a baseball game]

More past Barry Pearl re: Stan Lee:
The Marvel Method: Why And How? Reactions From The People Who Used it
Stan Lee, The Innovative Writer of His Time. And Ours.

Perhaps Stan's weakest attribute was coming up with a plot and developing it every single work day for ten years. He did rely on his artists in that regard. And as an editor he succeeded very well and got the best out of the creative people he worked with. They often developed the plot, he advanced the story in the dialogue. At DC, Julius Schwartz and Carmine Infantino told me that the artists often came up with the plots. Schwartz said he go to lunch and spend the entire afternoon with an artist think up a plot they would give to the writer. Also, at DC there were often no credits.

Update: Stan Lee In A Post-Fact World [Marvel In The Silver Age from 02018]

Derf Twitter thread: Stan Lee's real legacy wasn't enough for him

Tom Brevoort Twitter thread: biography makes Lee look the most selfish, craven, or malicious

Comic Book Yeti review: with interesting what works/what doesn't [what doesn't: "Rather than 'split the baby,' [Riesman] decides to give full custody to Kirby... he ends up contending that Lee likely had almost nothing to do with key books such as early Fantastic Four and Spider-Man comics... [suggesting Lee lied about everything] undermined many of Riesman's arguments]

Kim O'Connor on Twitter: 'So Stan Lee wasn't perfect- shrug?' isn't enough of a cultural reassessment of Lee because the Marvel Method was so exploitive to the artists

Riesman has seemed content to build his brand with such questionables as pestering Steve Ditko, musing the superhero genre prepares children for fascism, and whatever gatekeeping asshattery this was. Skip the new book and read the author's previous article writing about Lee, which will save your time and money, and which provides a good indication of what a Riesman biography of Stan Lee was going to look like.

[Kirby] said Lee was little more than a copy boy, filling in dialogue bubbles after Kirby had done the lion's share of the conceptual and writing work for any given issue.

From the book: Wally Wood to an interviewer:

I enjoyed working with Stan on Daredevil but for one thing. I had to make up the whole story. He was being paid for writing, and I was being paid for drawing, but he didnt have any ideas. I'd go in for a plotting session, and we'd just stare at each other until I came up with a storyline. I felt like I was writing the book but not being paid for writing.

Mark Evanier gets the final word; hoping to see his review of this book:

But my conclusion is that the comics we know to be created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby were created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby, not necessarily as 50-50 efforts and certainly not with Jack supplying only the visuals. I think Jack did a lot more than Stan - at least on the pages - and until fairly recently, got a lot less credit; likewise, Stan and Steve Ditko, Stan and Don Heck, Stan and Bill Everett, etc. The disparity in financial reward was even greater.
But that doesn't mean Stan did nothing or did nothing well. I have witnessed way too many Stan/Jack debates in my life and I think all are dead wrong if they lead to the conclusion that either contributed zero.

- -

The accurate biography of any successful person will dutifully report many failings and failures, the playoff chokes, the lost elections, the box-office bombs, overreaching for new heights, pathetic attempts to recapture past ones. Don't meet your heroes: they are imperfect and often immoral people with messy human lives, and there's plenty of Cheerios to piss in iconoclastically. We don't defend evil leaders because the comics and trains ran on time. Much of what we call greatness and wealth has been utterly dependent on cheap exploited labor.

It's no different with Stan Lee. We don't need worshipful Lee biographies nor Tribune puff pieces. Any accurate biography of Lee will legitimately report on his apparent insecurity-thirst for credit and credibility, and the uncool places it took him with the artists. Lee was a company man with a definition of "create" and a dynamic shorthand to interviewers (who were either uninterested in comics or looking to get a job from Lee) that was self-aggrandizing, sold comics, and protected Marvel against copyright litigation. Someone who is nice to you but mean to the waiter- or nice to your childhood but playing a role in ripping off the artist's ideas/writing/plotting- is not a nice person. We're all on Ditko/Kirby's side- Neilalien's Editorial Policy still stands. The Marvel Method was as innovative a way of getting lots of comics out the door as it was an innovative new method of exploitation. Lee will forever get the same asterisks and "problematic" labels as everyone else in our postmodern-internet messenger-is-message world that hasn't yet yielded better semantic mirrors to our shades of grey.

But the pendulum has swung far against Lee and it's hip to tear him down now. You saw it in the articles that came out when he died, and this biography has spawned a new wave of "it turns out Lee contributed very little at all" articles. The Comics Journal in 01995 has gone mainstream (this bio delights columnists there). Arguments like "Imperfect human", "Lee's salesmanship ensured there were artist jobs at all- even if they had poor pay, credit, and royalites, for disposable entertainment", "The artists loved working this way and understood it was work-for-hire (when there were no other jobs)", "Big movie paydays were not in anyone's imagination", etc., were never satisfying, and certainly not now. There's no sweeter clickbait than "the man co-behind those Marvel characters' interesting flaws was flawed himself" and kicking Beloved Low-Brow Pop-Culture Grandpa when he's down and cancelling him when he's dead. It's a sign of the comic-book field's eternal immaturity that the debate-meme-choices are this extreme binary of essentially either Lee hagiographies doing 100% as claimed, or simplistic 50%-50%, or Lee was a craven parasite who did 0%, loathed superheroes and his fate being intertwined with them, neglected his family, didn't rush to enlist for WWII fast enough, karmically died like a chump surrounded by fellow hucksters, etc.

While we vilify Lee's glory-hogging and the Marvel Method and the work-for-hire system- still ongoing, by the way- we can at the same time push back against one specific overreaction that Lee added nothing creatively to the artist-submitted page. Taking credit for absolutely everything and doing absolutely nothing are two different animals- and it's not all-or-nothing. We know how the sausage got made, and that 'Page 1, Panel 1' scripts aren't going to exist. We want an analysis of the Lee/Ditko/Kirby alchemy and friction and bottled-lightning. We want the source and percentages of who did what for every early Marvel comic book like the Lennon/McCartney percentages for every Beatles song (a process also full of disputes and different rememberings- it's amazing what pride and wallets can do to one's memory). That may not be possible. This is not a call for middle-road, mealy-mouthed, he-said/he-said, excuse-making.

Comics are words and pictures. Ditko/Kirby never reached without Lee the heights they did with Lee- nor Lee without them- and in this reader's opinion, the dialogue of their comics without Lee was terrible, and their comics lacked charm and warmth. The words are apparently Lee's- Ditko and Kirby don't seem corny enough in interviews to have written the purple prose of Marvel comics. You can get handed some of the greatest comic book ideas and artwork of all time at the perfect time- handed? our historians nobly teach us that Marvel basically stole them- but there's still another creator step that can't be brushed away. If you received a Kirby panel with a sidenote that said, "Thor says no door can resist hammer"- maybe that's Kirby doing 92% of the work and your actual speech balloon contents are the last 8%- then what would you write? You can still screw it up. An argument that Lee only did 8% is no triumph for Lee. If Kirby's work ends at "Thor says no door can resist hammer"- granted that's really far into the creation process- farther than Lee/Marvel ever acknowledged- and surely in Kirby's mind if he did that far then he did everything- but then the finished product is not Kirby 100%, and Lee is more than a copy boy. Everything still suggests it doesn't become the charming, funny, bombastically-titled, personality-filled, relatable, interconnected, reader-inclusive, good-selling Marvel Universe without Lee.

[26 April 02021]

- -

Penguin Random House Will Distribute Marvel Comics To Comics Stores

In a move that will likely transform the distribution of comics periodicals in North America, Penguin Random House Publisher Services has reached an agreement with Marvel to distribute its periodical comics and graphic novels to the comics shop market, also known as the direct market... PRHPS officially begins its distribution to direct market retailers for Marvel titles on October 1. The move marks a major change in the U.S. comics distribution market, which Diamond Comic Distributors has long dominated... PRHPS will offer Marvel comics to direct market retailers on nonreturnable wholesale terms... Marvel's new agreement with PRHPS follows the unexpected departure of DC from Diamond in 2020.

Marvel Signs Exclusive Multi-Year Distribution Deal With Penguin Random House As Direct Market Continues To Transform

Marvel Distribution Deal Part Of Long-Term Strategy For PRHPS

PRHPS believes it can help comic stores be more successful by adapting its learnings from the independent bookstore channel, which until Covid was thriving in the midst of competition from Amazon, mass merchants, and specialty retail chains, and which has proven surprisingly resilient even in the face of pandemic closures. In general terms, the learnings from the indie bookstore channel include the lesson that distributor investments in information technology, logistics, sales and service, and trade credit produce healthier retailers and more business.

Key Read: What's Behind Marvel's Move To PRH?

Marvel Comics Shifts To New Distributor In Industry-Rattling Move
["I can say purely as a private individual that Diamond has, for a long time, been unwilling or unable to modernize and support and grow the biz as needed for a healthy direct channel. And may not even be solvent. It would be imprudent for any publisher to not have a distribution contingency plan."]

Diamond Comic Distributors Loses Second Major Client In A Year

[1 April 02021]

- -

- -